BIR's Roadmap to 2028
Tax authorities around the world are investing heavily in digital transformation and online taxpayer services. It no longer focuses solely on revenue collection and enforcement.
By: John Paulo Garcia
17 Nov 2026 9 min read
When I was in college, one of the principles that was repeatedly emphasized was that the power of taxation is legislative in character. Only Congress has the authority to promulgate tax laws, determining what shall be taxed, who shall be taxed, how much tax shall be imposed, and how taxes shall be collected. To me, that makes perfect sense. After all, taxation is a burden imposed on its subjects, and it is only fitting that such power rests with the people’s elected representatives.
While I was also taught that the power of taxation has an administrative aspect, it was only when I gained a deeper understanding of the tax system that I realized the importance and weight of revenue regulations, circulars and other administrative issuances in practice. These issuances provide guidance, promote the uniform application of tax laws and inform taxpayers about their rights and obligations under the tax laws. Without them, confusion and uncertainty over the tax laws may prevail.
Yet administrative issuances can sometimes become a source of uncertainty themselves. This happens when these issuances appear to create consequences, obligations, or restrictions that cannot be clearly found in the law enacted by Congress or in established jurisprudence.
This brings us to an important question: Where does tax administration end and lawmaking begin?
Interpretative Power and Rule-Making Authority of the Secretary of Finance and Commissioner of Internal Revenue
The National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) of 1997, as amended, vests in the Commissioner of Internal Revenue (CIR) the exclusive and original authority to interpret the provisions of the Tax Code and other tax laws, subject to review by the Secretary of Finance (SOF). In exercising this power, the CIR issues interpretative rules, usually in the form of revenue memorandum circulars, that merely clarify, or explain the law. The purpose of these issuances is merely to construe the statute being administered and do no more than interpret the law.
Separately, Section 244 of the NIRC also authorizes the SOF, upon the recommendation of the CIR, to promulgate rules and regulations necessary for the enforcement of the provisions of the NIRC. This rule-making power is quasi-legislative in nature and is usually exercised through the issuance of revenue regulations, which may supplement the law and prescribe implementing details within the limits of the delegation granted by Congress.
The distinction is important because interpretative issuances only interpret or explain existing legal obligations. On the other hand, legislative rules are a form of subordinate legislation through which an administrative agency exercises delegated legislative authority to supplement a statute and fill in the details necessary for its implementation. Legislative rules may add additional requirements, but only to the extent authorized by Congress and consistent with the law being implemented. They cannot, however, create tax liabilities or impose obligations that have no sufficient basis in law. Because legislative rules carry the force and effect of law and may affect rights and obligations, they generally require prior notice and opportunity for public participation before becoming effective.
Both the interpretative power and rulemaking authority of the SOF and BIR must be exercised within the bounds of the law and in accordance with due process. Administrative issuances cannot amend, expand, restrict, or nullify the very statutes they are intended to interpret or implement. To do so would effectively transform administrative action into an exercise of legislative power, which is constitutionally vested in Congress.
Boundaries of Administrative Power in Practice
A recent example illustrating the limits of administrative rulemaking is the decision of the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) declaring Revenue Regulations (RR) No. 16-2023 and the related Revenue Memorandum Circular (RMC) No. 8-2024 void.
RR No. 16-2023 imposed withholding tax on gross remittances by e-market place operators and digital financial services providers (DFSPs) to the sellers/merchants for the goods and services sold or paid through their platforms or facilities. On the other hand, RMC No. 8-2024 clarified certain provisions of RR No. 16-2023.
The affected taxpayers who challenged the issuances before the court argued that the SOF and CIR violated the Constitution by usurping legislative functions through the expansion of the objects of taxation without statutory authority. They likewise contended that the SOF and CIR exceeded their authority by prescribing a withholding tax beyond the limits provided under Section 57(B) of the NIRC, among other grounds. The taxpayers further argued that RR No. 16-2023, as well as the related RMC No. 8-2024, were issued without prior public consultation and compliance with due process requirements.
The CTA determined that RR No. 16-2023 is a legislative rule. Prior to its issuance, e-market place operators and DFSPs were not required to withhold tax from their gross remittances to sellers/merchants for the goods and services sold or collected through their platforms. Therefore, it created new duties and responsibilities that were not previously imposed under existing regulations. While the CTA did not discuss whether prescribing this new requirement fell within the authority of the SOF and CIR as the affected taxpayers argued, the CTA ruled that RR No. 16-2023 had no legal force and effect because the SOF and BIR failed to demonstrate compliance with the requirements of prior notice, hearing, and publication.
RMC No. 8-2024 was determined to be merely an interpretative rule, hence, the requirements of prior notice and hearing did not apply. Nonetheless, given that RMC No. 8-2024 was promulgated solely to clarify the provisions of RR No. 16-2023, which had already been declared void, it could no longer stand independently and was likewise deemed to be without force and effect.
Previously, RMC Nos. 05-2024 and 38-2024 also stirred some controversy regarding the tax treatment of cross-border services. As background, RMC Nos. 05-2024 and 38-2024 were issued by the BIR to clarify the tax treatment of cross-border and adopt the “benefit-received theory” in determining the situs of taxation for purposes of income tax and value-added tax (VAT). However, many taxpayers argued that the circulars expanded the application of the Supreme Court's ruling in Aces Philippines Cellular Satellite Corp. v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue (the Aces case) and departed from the rules expressly provided in the NIRC.
The controversy stems from the fact that Section 42 of the NIRC generally treats income from services as sourced where the services are performed. However, under the twin circulars, there may be instances where, even if the services are performed abroad, the income payments for these services can still be considered to be derived from sources within the Philippines.
The validity of these circulars is currently being challenged before the CTA. A Writ of Preliminary Injunction was issued enjoining the CIR from implementing or executing in any manner RMC Nos. 05-2024 and 38-2024 while the case is pending, unless earlier lifted by the court.
The foregoing judicial proceedings underscore the importance of recognizing the limits of the administrative power of the BIR and the SOF. While these authorities may interpret and implement tax laws, they cannot rewrite the law under the guise of interpretation and implementation. Administrative issuances must likewise comply with applicable procedural and due process requirements.
The Cost of Regulatory Uncertainties
Beyond legal questions, administrative issuances that are perceived to go beyond the bounds of the law often create uncertainty.
As a result of these issuances, taxpayers may find themselves caught between complying with an administrative interpretation and relying on the text of the law itself. Yet taxpayers cannot simply disregard newly issued regulations or circulars even while questioning their validity. Taxpayers are often compelled to comply while such issuances remain in effect to avoid possible tax assessments and penalties.
More importantly, when an issuance introduces obligations or tax consequences that are not readily apparent from the tax laws, taxpayers may struggle to assess their real tax exposures, contractual obligations, and even investment decisions. Compliance with administrative issuances requires time, effort, and resources and may necessitate the modification of accounting systems, the revision of contracts with customers and suppliers, or the engagement of professional advisers to understand and implement new requirements.
The uncertainty becomes even more profound when the validity of an issuance is challenged before the courts. Until a final decision is rendered, taxpayers are often left navigating a legal gray area and must balance compliance risks against the possibility that the issuance may ultimately be declared invalid. The practical consequences for the taxpayers arise immediately, while legal certainty may take years to emerge.
Most taxpayers can adapt to taxes imposed by laws and can generally plan for compliance requirements. However, what is far more difficult to manage are abrupt shifts in administrative interpretations of tax laws, coupled with uncertainty over whether the very issuances imposing such interpretations will withstand judicial scrutiny.
Takeaways
Administrative issuances are an indispensable part of tax administration. The tax laws enacted by Congress cannot possibly provide for every detail and anticipate all situations or transactions that may arise. For this reason, the authority granted to the DOF and CIR to interpret, promulgate administrative rules, and implement tax laws is both necessary and practical.
Indeed, the task of administering the complex Philippine tax system is no small undertaking, and the efforts of the BIR in enforcing and operationalizing our tax laws deserve recognition. At their best, administrative issuances provide clarity, promote the uniform application of the law, and support voluntary compliance. Difficulties arise, however, when taxpayers perceive that an issuance imposes obligations, tax consequences, or restrictions that cannot be readily traced to the governing statute.
Ultimately, the challenge is in drawing the line between faithful implementation of the law and the inadvertent exercise of legislative power. By remaining firmly anchored to legislative intent and the limits set by the tax laws, administrative issuances can promote certainty, strengthen voluntary compliance, and foster greater confidence in the tax system - a result that ultimately benefits both taxpayers and the government.
As published in BusinessWorld, dated 17 November 2026
Tax authorities around the world are investing heavily in digital transformation and online taxpayer services. It no longer focuses solely on revenue collection and enforcement.
A refund claim can take five to six years from the time the claim is filed with the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), to the CTA, to the Supreme Court, and then back to the BIR.
Ask any law student about their daily routine, and you will hear a familiar story of daily survival against an unrelenting avalanche of cases.